Wednesday, May 14, 2008

Diane Benson Featured in Article About Women Candidates

AK-AL U.S. House candidate, Democrat Diane Benson, is one of the woman candidates featured in an article published on the progressive web site, Truthout, late last week. The article, by Maya Schenwar, is titled Women in the Running.

Although the article starts out by stating the campaign of Sen. Hillary Clinton for the Democratic Party's presidential nomination has opened doors of perception and acceptability for other woman candidates as well, Schenwar notes that "the struggle for women's voices to be heard in the political sphere will be far from over.

"Despite all the focus on Clinton's gender over the course of her campaign," Schenwar continues, "there's been surprisingly little discussion of the gender makeup of the political system as a whole."

The author briefly mentions the ongoing campaigns of Maryland activist Donna Edwards and former Kansas City, Missouri Mayor, Kay Barnes. But it centers around Benson's Alaska campaign, and old-school Democratic Party perceptions that men are more electable than women. Schenwar cites a Gallup poll, taken before the 2000 election, that found "more than three-quarters of Americans reject the idea that, 'On the whole, men make better political leaders than women do.'"

Alaska's Diane Benson, who garnered about 94,000 votes against Don Young in 2006, while spending only something over $200,000 in a grassroots campaign, compared then rather favorably against the gubernatorial campaign of Tony Knowles and Ethan Berkowitz. The latter males, while spending well over $1,000,000 on their campaign against a woman they outspent by over $300,000, pulled in only about 97,000 votes. And they lost in a three-way race against two Republican-oriented tickets.

In 2006, the Alaska Democratic Party was discouraged by the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee's then-chair, Rahm Emanuel, from supporting Benson's campaign against Young. Emanuel's strategy of concentrating on supporting male candidates who favored anti-union free trade treaties, lax regulation of the mortgage industry, and were willing to rubber-stamp George Bush's war policies, was contrasted in 2006, by Democratic National Committee Chairman, Howard Dean's 50-state strategy, which tended to back more progressive candidates, and far more females than did Emanuel.

After the 2006 elections, as the corporate media credited Emanuel's strategy as having brought control of the U.S. House to the Democrats, more savvy observers wrote that had Dean's strategy been followed more fervently, the Democratic Party's pickups would have been more considerable. And far less likely to enable George Bush's failing, flailing policies.

The now-disgraced Jake Metcalfe's fervent support of Rahm Emanuel and his anti-progressive policies in 2006, have been replaced in 2008's Alaska campaign map, by Emanuel's warm embrace of Ethan Berkowitz's campaign. Emanuel has emerged as the most fervent member of the Joe Lieberman-founded, anti-net neutrality, anti-union, pro-international deregulation group, the New Democrat Coalition. The NDC is, in reality, a kind of Blue Dog Democrat lite. Though Berkowitz has stated to me, that "under no circumstances will he feel obligated to Emanuel for the [Emanuel's] largesse," that's not likely, though, for any freshman member of the house. Berkowitz has to sound tough, though, to face off against the considerably tougher, considerably taller, Benson.

Benson has pulled in endorsements from the National Organization of Women, the National Women's Caucus, the Alaska Women's Caucus, and is garnishing increasing material support from Emily's List, one of the country's most effective PACs. Recently, when two Alaska state-level functionaries of the National Womens' Caucus participated in a fundraiser for Berkowitz, they were admonished by the national organization.

Benson's support in Alaska's Native community is growing rapidly. There are several reasons for this, not least of which was the Native and women's rights communities' responses to Anchorage Daily News reporter Lisa Demer's May 1 article, Native Women Address Violence Rates. Benson, who before the article, had participated in scores of such confidential conferences in Alaska and elsewhere, once the horrific specifics of her years in foster care as a child became public, decided to use the scrutiny this violence is now getting as an opportunity to bring more attention to this important issue.

This Friday, Benson and Berkowitz will be attending the Hispanic Affairs Council of Alaska's candidate forum. Don Young, Gabrielle LeDoux and Sean Parnell are also invited, but will probably be phoning in to the forum. The questions, to be handled by Mat-Su Valley Democratic Party activist, Erick Corduro, will be on immigration, education, healthcare and the economy.

images: top - Alaska's long-standing peace activist, Ruth Sheridan, military mom-peace activist Diane Benson, WWII U.S. Navy Veteran and transportation visionary, Lorna Kanus; middle - Diane Benson on her Harley at the 2006 Memorial Day commemoration at Byers Lake; bottom - Diane Benson - not in heels - and Ethan Berkowitz at this winter's AFN Convention in Fairbanks

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

For shame. By referring to "... Diane Benson - not in heels - and Ethan Berkowitz..." the author of this piece is obviously attacking Mr. Berkowitz for his physical stature (and not his stature as a candidate).

Wouldn't it be better to extoll Ms. Benson's vast legislative experience, her clarion positions on the issues, etc. (unless, of course, those qualities are totally lacking, and her only qualifications are that she is taller than Berkowitz and her gender/life story).

The idiotic phrase ("now-disgraced") to describe Jake Metcalfe is also way out of line --but Jake is no longer a candidate, so I guess he's fair game?

One should be able to expect better from the most self-righteous blogger around. Give us a break.

Anonymous said...

Of course I would expect an Anonymous comment to focus on the most trivial aspects of this post. Ethan is short; so what; who cares; if he, and obviously you, are that thin skinned about it, wait until the political cartoonists get into it. And yes, Jake is out of the race and some would say that he is disgraced perhaps primarily for never really taking full responsibility for what he should have known was going on in his own campaign. It seems likely that he knew what was going on- maybe he did, maybe he didn’t; but he should have.

And, by the way, some might consider that vast and varied life experiences in the real world ARE INDEED more important for a US Representative than a privileged upbringing (remember Geroge W?) and legislative experience that accomplished very little.

Philip Munger said...

Jake IS disgraced, mostly because he couldn't stand tall enough to come right out with something straightforward and manly as his campaign spun out. He's also disgraced for the unseemly way he left his post as chair back in 2007.

I brought up Berkowitz's height disadvantage to raise awareness for those who - I hope! - come to tomorrow's Affairs Council forum on issues important to their community.

Mr. Berkowitz was noted by observers at the Kodiak FishCom candidate forum, to be going to great lengths not to be caught on camera next to other candidates. It was thought at the time that he was reluctant to appear to be shorter than some of the other candidates in attendance.

There are a fair number of articles available on the web about how male candidates deal with being photographed next to taller female opponents. Some of them are hilarious. So, it isn't just Ethan.

There's a photo in the rotation on his campaign site of Ethan sitting on a dogsled that has a campaign sign on it. Compare that to the photo of Benson on her Harley, attached to this post.

Enuff said.......

Anonymous said...

Phil, I assume you've seen this at Kos. http://www.dailykos.com/storyonly/2008/5/15/12326/5308

What's with him not including Diane in his polling? I thought that was supposed to be a "progressive" web site.

Philip Munger said...

Kos has contributed at least $1,000 to Berkowitz, and raised more. Much more.

He has yet to state, in any of his Alaska posts that mention Ethan, that Berkowitz is in a primary contest.

I regard Kos's pattern of hiding the facts to be more serious than my pointing out that Diane Benson is taller than is Ethan.

Anonymous said...

So do I. I believe you've tried to educate him on this, haven't you? Does he have any explanation? Seems rather sexist (or something) to me, and rather despicable for a supposedly progressive site. It just really bugs me.

I don't post over there, so I can't really call him on it, but I've been letting everybody at Democratic Underground know about his bias (since that's where I saw the link to the poll posted), and have been encouraging them to send contributions Diane's way, if they're looking for the "real" progressive candidate.

Philip Munger said...

I'm hoping that the major differences between Ethan's "there's nothing wrong with our medical care system that can't be tweaked into shape" stance and Benson's comprehensive approach to health care reform become important aspects in the forum.

I'm sure Erick will deal with this conscientiously....

clark said...

this is one middle-aged white guy who'll be coming out of the woodwork to vote for her and watching with glee when she whips ethan's, and then don young's ass! all the way, baby, yeah!!

Anonymous said...

Phillip - Picking up on your comment regarding health care, I compared Ethan's stated position on his website with Diane's stated position. You are correct. Diane Benson gives a ringing endorsement of Universal Health Care as the cornerstone of her approach, while Ethan Berkowitz mentions a bunch of half-way measures that will not improve health care for most Americans and certainly not for uninsured Alaskans. Clearly Berkowitz does not support UHC.

The lack of access to health care is a national embarassment and a serious Alaska problem.

I think Diane should elevate the visibility of this difference with Ethan. UHC is important to a lot of Democrats and Independents.

Anonymous said...

Is Ethan not very tall? I have met him and remember him as being quite tall. I am 5'8" but my height issue says a lot about my impression of a person!

Phil, get that picture of the Hog driving diva out all over the place-- I admire Hogs and their owners!