The United Nations Security Council met Wednesday evening, resolving nothing. Egypt has recalled its ambassador from Tel Aviv, and Egyptian Prime Minister Hesham Kandil will be visiting Gaza, possibly today.
Since Operation Cast Lead in 2008-2009, Israel has gained no allies. But opponents of Israeli policies in Israel, in the occupied territories of the West Bank, in Gaza, and internationally, have increased markedly, mostly after the senselessly brutal attacks upon Turkish and American civilians on the MV Mavi Marmara, which left nine dead, some brutally executed at short range after surrendering.
The IDF began the operation on twitter, putting out a lot of tweets, some of which were either answered by Hamas-connected twitter accounts, or fake Israeli ones, designed to appear as if from Hamas. Currently, a trending hashtag is a tasteless niche, #HamasBumperStickers:
Since yesterday, anonymous and other global hacking communities have been taking down Israeli government and NGO web sites. The image at the top of this article is a screenshot I took of a Mexican anonymous collective's takedown of Advocate Israel.
The Washington Post just published an article titled Is Hamas Winning the Twitter War?
Today, Israel launched a military strike on Hamas in the Gaza Strip – and a complimentary social media campaign, which has chronicled much of the “Pillar of Defense” operation with polished video and photos. But despite the Israeli Defense Force’s calculated deployment on Twitter, Facebook and Flickr (plus a blog and game platform that awards points for “spread[ing] IDF content”), Israel might not actually be winning the Twitter war. By one metric, it’s losing 150 to one.
As the terms “Gaza” and “Hamas” trended globally, Twitter users staked out hashtags for their respective causes. On the Israeli side: #PillarofDefense, the name of the latest military operation, which appears to have been started by the IDF account. For the Palestinians, if not necessarily for Hamas: #GazaUnderAttack, #Gazzeateşaltında (Turkish for the same) and several other foreign-language derivatives. As of 5 p.m., the IDF’s tag had received 808 mentions, while the #GazaUnderAttack derivations had around 120,000.
Given the scale of Israel’s social media operation, that’s an awfully small piece of the audience. The IDF made Pillar of Defense a uniquely social-oriented operation, announcing it with a tweet rather than a traditional press conference.Today on twitter, while more cyber battles are underway, the battle is also being fought on other fronts. Just as some thought the 2008-2009 Gaza War was partially a ploy by then-Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni to gain advantage in the February 2009 Israeli parliamentary elections, so this campaign may be part of the actions being taken by Likud and Yisrael Beiteinu to leverage their advantage in the upcoming January 22nd parliamentary elections there:
Since then, the account @IDFSpokesperson has kept up a day-long stream of ultra-shareable posts, with more videos, graphics and calls for retweet than a social media best-practice class. Between videos of rocket strikes and taunts to Hamas, the IDF urged followers to repost images like their red-tinged graphic of deceased Hamas leader Ahmed Jabari, which bears the stamp “eliminated” in capital letters. Followers retweeted that photo nearly 600 times; another, bearing the caption “RT if you think #Israel has the right to defend itself,” has been shared more than 1,700 times.
Netanyahu's partner in the upcoming election, his Foreign Minister, Avigdor Lieberman, was quoted yesterday as saying "Jewish state more important than democratic state. We [are] the only Jewish state so more important to be Jewish."
Social media tools used by military, anonymous hackers reaching out to take down sites and services worldwide, cell phone zones cut off through a variety of means legal or illegal. 21st century war in a very urban setting - Gaza.